Lucid Trading vs Tradeify: verified payouts, traffic and drawdown rules
Lucid Trading vs Tradeify, as of 16 Nov 2026: Tradeify paid $47,155,782 in verified payouts over the last 30 days while Lucid Trading has no verified figure (Payout Junction does not cover Lucid Trading); Lucid Trading has the larger audience (8.32M website visits in Sep 2026 against 5.73M); their flagship challenges are about equally hard (a 61% simulated pass probability at Lucid Trading against 61% at Tradeify for the same trader).
- Payout Junction does not cover Lucid Trading, so PropWorld shows no payout figures and no Payout Reliability Score (PRS) for it. That is a coverage gap, not evidence that Lucid Trading does not pay.
- Payout figures are verified by Payout Junction, not by PropWorld; website visits are third-party monthly estimates; pass probabilities are PropWorld's own Monte Carlo simulation for a trader with a 50% win rate, 1:1.5 risk-to-reward and 1% risk per trade, not pass rates reported by either firm.
Updated
Lucid Trading vs Tradeify: full comparison
| Metric | Lucid Trading | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Market | Futures | Futures |
| Country | US | US |
| Founded | 2025 | 2024 |
| PropWorld PRS | not available | 89/100 (Exceptional) |
| Verified payouts, last 30 days | no record | $47,155,782 |
| Verified payouts in the last 30 days (count) | no record | 29,565 |
| Verified payouts, all-time | no record | $451,655,668 |
| Median verified payout | no record | $1,543 |
| Last verified payout | no record | 15 Nov 2026 |
| Monthly website visits (Sep 2026) | 8.32M | 5.73M |
| Visits, month over month | -13.3% | +49.8% |
| TrustPilot rating | 4.6/5 | 4.5/5 |
| TrustPilot reviews | 8,463 | 6,473 |
| PropWorld's review | not yet rated | 9/10 |
| Max allocation | $150,000 | $150,000 |
| Trading platforms | Quantower, Ninja Trader, Tradovate | NinjaTrader, Quantower, R Trader, Sierra Chart, Tradesea, TradingView, Tradovate, WealthCharts |
| Challenge types | 1 Step | 1 Step |
| Flagship challenge | LucidFlex, $50,000 | Select Evaluation, $50,000 |
| Profit target | 6% | 6% |
| Max loss | 4% end-of-day trailing | 4% end-of-day trailing |
| Daily loss limit | none | none |
| Consistency rule | 40% | 40% |
| Evaluation fee | $115 | $165 |
| Profit split | 90% | 90% |
| Simulated pass probability, baseline profile | 61% | 61% |
| Simulated pass probability, thinner edge profile | 41% | 41% |
| Simulated pass probability, half the risk profile | 84% | 84% |
| Expected attempts to pass (baseline) | 1.6 | 1.6 |
| True cost to funded (baseline) | $189 | $269 |
Verified payouts: Lucid Trading vs Tradeify
Payout Junction has no verified payout record for Lucid Trading, so PropWorld shows no payout figures and no Payout Reliability Score (PRS) for it. This is a coverage gap, not evidence that the firm does not pay. Tradeify has paid out $451,655,668 to funded traders across 233,867 payouts verified by Payout Junction, most recently on 15 Nov 2026.
Tradeify paid $47,155,782 in verified payouts over the last 30 days while Lucid Trading has no verified figure (Payout Junction does not cover Lucid Trading). Payout Junction verifies the payouts and publishes the totals; PropWorld republishes them and does not verify payouts itself.
Website traffic: Lucid Trading vs Tradeify
Lucid Trading received 8.32M website visits in Sep 2026, down 13.3% from the previous month. Tradeify received 5.73M website visits in Sep 2026, up 49.8% from the previous month. These are third-party monthly estimates of visits to each firm's website, not the firms' own analytics and not a count of funded traders.
Reputation and PRS: Lucid Trading vs Tradeify
Lucid Trading holds a 4.6 out of 5 rating on TrustPilot from 8,463 reviews. Tradeify holds a 4.5 out of 5 rating on TrustPilot from 6,473 reviews. Those ratings are TrustPilot's, not PropWorld's.
Lucid Trading has no Payout Reliability Score (PRS) because PropWorld has no Payout Junction verified payout record for this firm yet; a missing score is never shown as 0.
Tradeify scores 89/100 (Exceptional) on PropWorld's Payout Reliability Score (PRS): scale 30, activity 19, audience 13, momentum 9, operator rating 18, tenure 1.
Challenge rules and drawdown: Lucid Trading vs Tradeify
Lucid Trading's flagship challenge is the LucidFlex: on a $50,000 account the profit target is 6%, with 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule, for a $115 fee. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Lucid Trading's LucidFlex hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 75% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 5 points: without it the pass probability is 65%.
Tradeify's flagship challenge is the Select Evaluation: on a $50,000 account the profit target is 6%, with 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule, for a $165 fee. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Tradeify's Select Evaluation hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 76% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 4 points: without it the pass probability is 66%.
For the same trader, their flagship challenges are about equally hard (a 61% simulated pass probability at Lucid Trading against 61% at Tradeify for the same trader).
Pass probability & true cost to funded: Lucid Trading vs Tradeify
Lucid Trading
In PropWorld's Monte Carlo simulation, a trader with a 50% win rate, 1:1.5 risk-to-reward and 1% risk per trade passes Lucid Trading's LucidFlex on a $50,000 account in 61% of 20,000 simulated attempts. At the $115 fee that is 1.6 expected attempts and a true cost to funded of about $189; $345 buys a 90% chance of passing at least once. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Lucid Trading's LucidFlex hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 75% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 5 points: without it the pass probability is 65%.
| Trader profile | Inputs | Pass probability | Expected attempts | True cost to funded | 90% budget | Expected trading days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline (the simulator's default inputs) | 50% win · 1:1.5 · 1% risk · 60 trades/month | 61% | 1.6 | $189 | $345 | 12 |
| Thinner edge (win rate 5 points lower, half the expectancy) | 45% win · 1:1.5 · 1% risk · 60 trades/month | 41% | 2.5 | $283 | $575 | 18 |
| Half the risk (same edge, half the size per trade) | 50% win · 1:1.5 · 0.5% risk · 60 trades/month | 84% | 1.2 | $137 | $230 | 16 |
| Challenge | Loss rules | Account | Profit target | Fee | Pass probability | If the drawdown were static | Without the daily loss limit | Without the consistency rule | True cost to funded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidFlex | 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule | $50,000 | 6% | $115 | 61% | 75% | no such rule | 65% | $189 |
| LucidDaily | 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule | $50,000 | 6% | $122 | 60% | 75% | no such rule | 65% | $202 |
| LucidPro | 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit | $50,000 | 6% | $172 | 66% | 77% | no such rule | no such rule | $262 |
Tradeify
In PropWorld's Monte Carlo simulation, a trader with a 50% win rate, 1:1.5 risk-to-reward and 1% risk per trade passes Tradeify's Select Evaluation on a $50,000 account in 61% of 20,000 simulated attempts. At the $165 fee that is 1.6 expected attempts and a true cost to funded of about $269; $495 buys a 90% chance of passing at least once. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Tradeify's Select Evaluation hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 76% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 4 points: without it the pass probability is 66%.
| Trader profile | Inputs | Pass probability | Expected attempts | True cost to funded | 90% budget | Expected trading days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline (the simulator's default inputs) | 50% win · 1:1.5 · 1% risk · 60 trades/month | 61% | 1.6 | $269 | $495 | 12 |
| Thinner edge (win rate 5 points lower, half the expectancy) | 45% win · 1:1.5 · 1% risk · 60 trades/month | 41% | 2.4 | $403 | $825 | 18 |
| Half the risk (same edge, half the size per trade) | 50% win · 1:1.5 · 0.5% risk · 60 trades/month | 84% | 1.2 | $197 | $330 | 16 |
| Challenge | Loss rules | Account | Profit target | Fee | Pass probability | If the drawdown were static | Without the daily loss limit | Without the consistency rule | True cost to funded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Select Evaluation | 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule | $50,000 | 6% | $165 | 61% | 76% | no such rule | 66% | $269 |
| Growth Evaluation | 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit | $50,000 | 6% | $145 | 65% | 77% | no such rule | no such rule | $224 |
Each figure is 20,000 simulated attempts on PropWorld's Monte Carlo engine, the same one behind the Prop Firm Simulator: every attempt replays the profile one trade at a time against the profit targets, the drawdown type, the daily loss limit and the consistency rule, with no time limit. The runs are seeded, so a figure changes only when a rule or a price does. Risk per trade is a percentage of the nominal account, so 1% of a $50,000 account is $500 whatever the loss limit is. True cost to funded is the evaluation fee times the expected number of attempts; activation, reset and data fees are not included. These are model results for a trader who holds a fixed positive edge: they isolate what the rules cost, and they are far above the pass rates firms report, which are dominated by traders without one. They are not a pass rate published by Lucid Trading and Tradeify and not a prediction. Rules and prices as checked by PropWorld on 2026-11-12; confirm them on the firm's own site before buying. Run the simulator with your own numbers.
Lucid Trading vs Tradeify: questions
- Which pays more, Lucid Trading or Tradeify?
- Tradeify paid $47,155,782 in verified payouts over the last 30 days while Lucid Trading has no verified figure (Payout Junction does not cover Lucid Trading). Payout Junction verifies the payouts and publishes the totals; PropWorld republishes them and does not verify payouts itself. Figures as of 16 Nov 2026.
- Which gets more website traffic, Lucid Trading or Tradeify?
- Lucid Trading has the larger audience (8.32M website visits in Sep 2026 against 5.73M). These are third-party monthly estimates of website visits, not the firms' own analytics.
- Which has stricter drawdown rules, Lucid Trading or Tradeify?
- Lucid Trading's flagship challenge is the LucidFlex: on a $50,000 account the profit target is 6%, with 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule, for a $115 fee. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Lucid Trading's LucidFlex hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 75% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 5 points: without it the pass probability is 65%. Tradeify's flagship challenge is the Select Evaluation: on a $50,000 account the profit target is 6%, with 4% end-of-day trailing max loss, no daily loss limit, 40% consistency rule, for a $165 fee. The end-of-day trailing drawdown is what makes Tradeify's Select Evaluation hard: with the same 4% loss limit held static the same trader passes 76% of the time, so the trailing rule cuts the pass probability by 15 percentage points. The 40% consistency rule costs a further 4 points: without it the pass probability is 66%. For the simulated trader the two are about equally hard to pass.
- Is it cheaper to get funded at Lucid Trading or Tradeify?
- In PropWorld's simulation the true cost to funded is about $189 at Lucid Trading (LucidFlex $50,000, $115 fee, 61% pass probability) against about $269 at Tradeify (Select Evaluation $50,000, $165 fee, 61%), for a trader with a 50% win rate, 1:1.5 risk-to-reward and 1% risk per trade. Evaluation fees only; the account sizes differ where the two firms sell different sizes.
- Is Lucid Trading or Tradeify more reliable on payouts?
- Lucid Trading has no Payout Reliability Score (PRS) because PropWorld has no Payout Junction verified payout record for this firm yet; a missing score is never shown as 0. Tradeify scores 89/100 (Exceptional) on PropWorld's Payout Reliability Score (PRS): scale 30, activity 19, audience 13, momentum 9, operator rating 18, tenure 1. PRS measures observed, verified payout activity and public commercial signals; it is not an audit and not a guarantee that either firm will pay a given trader.
- Where do these payout figures come from?
- Payout figures are tracked and verified by Payout Junction, an independent service that publishes verified payout totals for prop firms. PropWorld republishes those figures, keeps them as a history, and links each firm to its source record. Payout verification is Payout Junction's, not PropWorld's. Absence of verified payouts is not evidence that a firm does not pay.
Go deeper
- Lucid Trading: full data
- Tradeify: full data
- Best prop firms
- Best futures prop firms
- Prop Firm Simulator
- All firms side by side
Related comparisons
Payouts as of · refreshed twice daily from Payout JunctionTraffic: · refreshed monthly